[Financial News] With oversight of cheating using artificial intelligence (AI) being tightened for the 2027 College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT), whether the state can be held legally liable if exam authorities fail to prevent cheating has emerged as a key issue. The debate intensified recently after AI-assisted cheating by the top scorer on the tax accountant exam went undetected at the test site and came to light when the person turned themselves in. Legal experts say the focus should be not on the failure to detect cheating itself, but on whether preventive measures at the time were adequate and whether actual harm occurred. Who Is Responsible for Failing to Detect Cheating? On the 19th, the government assigned about 8,400 additional staff to 1,312 CSAT test sites nationwide, including about 1,800 staff dedicated to smart devices and about 6,600 hallway proctors. It also stepped up measures to prevent new forms of cheating, including inspecting test takers’ glasses and checking for miniature cameras hidden in clothing. The controversy widened after the top scorer on the 63rd tax accountant exam admitted to cheating using a miniature camera and generative AI, among other methods, and turned themselves in to police on the 15th. The cheating was not detected even at a test site with proctors on duty, and the government has begun procedures to invalidate the exam and suspend the person’s eligibility to sit for exams for five years. It is also noteworthy that cheating with smart glasses had already been detected in another national qualification exam. The Human Resources Development Service of Korea said it drew up measures for managing electronic and communications devices in May and used training materials on identifying smart glasses for the tax accountant exam in July. Although measures were in place, legal experts say it should be separately examined whether the supervision methods at the time were adequate in light of the known risks. Hyeon Min-seok, an attorney at YK Law Firm, stressed that “a claim for damages is possible,” but added that “liability is not established simply because cheating went undetected.” His point was that a causal link must be established between inadequate preventive measures, the failure to detect the cheating, and a particular candidate’s failure to pass. Wi Jong-uk, an attorney at D&A LLC, said there could be grounds for liability if required oversight procedures were not put in place even after new cheating methods became known. “If they failed to put in place any of the oversight procedures that should obviously have been established,” Wi said, “and that resulted in a particular test taker suffering harm by failing the exam, it seems possible that the state could be held liable for its supervisory role under the State Compensation Act.” Lee Je-nam, an attorney at Daeryun Law Firm, said the issue could be contested if the previous supervision methods remained in place for the second exam on July 18, after cheating with smart glasses had been detected in other national qualification exams in May and June. This is a conditional analysis that the effectiveness of the measures should be examined, not an assertion that the supervision methods actually remained unchanged. In October last year, the Supreme Court overturned and remanded a lower court ruling in a state compensation case stemming from a grading error on the tax accountant exam, saying that a breach of internal guidelines alone does not automatically establish liability for damages. Although grading errors and negligence in supervision are different matters, the ruling is regarded as a relevant precedent because it distinguishes between unlawful conduct by a state agency and liability for damages. Choi Seung-hwan, an attorney at Barun Law LLC, said that “there may be grounds to find a breach of the duty of care if reasonable preventive and supervisory measures required at the time were neglected despite known risks.” He added that “if abnormally high scores or statistical anomalies were found, the need for post-exam verification could also be considered.” However, he cautioned that “a high score in itself is not evidence of cheating, and whether the law requires such post-exam verification must be determined based on the specific circumstances.” Relief for Those Harmed Is Difficult... Concerns About Infringement of Fundamental Rights It is also difficult for harmed test takers to obtain relief. This year, 722 people passed the tax accountant exam overall, including 712 who passed after sitting all subjects in the second-stage exam—a number that alone exceeds the minimum of 700 successful candidates. Canceling the pass of one person who cheated does not automatically mean that the next-ranked candidate passes. Even if candidates sue to overturn a decision that they failed or seek damages, they must prove, among other things, that they would have passed had there been no cheating and that they actually suffered harm. Oh Jeong-ik, an attorney on the TIF (Tech, IP & Fintech) team at One Law Partners, said there are legal grounds for holding the state liable, but that “in practice, it seems unlikely that state compensation liability would be recognized under the legal principles.” He explained that candidates must prove the harm suffered by each individual and the causal link, rather than merely alleging negligence in supervision. Lee Je-nam of Daeryun Law Firm cited a ruling that awarded compensation for emotional distress after an exam authority’s error in a CSAT bell-ringing incident, but said, “That case involved the exam authority directly disrupting the test of the candidate concerned, so it would be difficult to apply it as is to this case.” Some have also warned that tighter supervision could lead to infringements of fundamental rights. Oh Jeong-ik of One Law Partners said that “full-body searches and the installation of closed-circuit television (CCTV) could raise issues involving personal liberty and privacy.” Hyeon Min-seok of YK Law Firm likewise said that “infringements of fundamental rights, such as freedom to choose one’s occupation, can be discussed only in exceptional cases where the state has failed to take even minimum preventive measures.” Wi Jong-uk of D&A LLC also stressed that “the exam administrator’s duty to manage and supervise appears to be more directly connected to issues under the State Compensation Act.” Legal experts broadly agree that although advances in AI technology are changing how exams are supervised, whether the state is liable for compensation requires a separate determination. The key criteria being considered are the relationship between the response to known risks and the failure to detect cheating, and the specific harm suffered by test takers. [email protected] Yu Seon-jun Reporter
-
President Lee Approves 'Special Counsel Act on Fabricated Indictments' ... Takes Effect Immediately Upon Promulgation on the 19th
-
China’s Ministry of Commerce Confirms Substantive Agreement on Phase Two of China–South Korea FTA... Implementation Plan Drawn Up
-
"What's All the Fuss About?" Why Daiso's 'Pencils and Sharpeners' Sold Out Ahead of the CSAT
-
A Last-Ditch Gambit for North Korea-U.S. Talks? U.S. Abstains From UN Resolution on North Korean Human Rights for First Time, Causing a Stir
















