Sunday, November 22, 2026

Gift Tax Assessed Using 'Actual Transaction Price' of Apartment in Neighboring Building... Court: 'Lawful Disposition'

Input
2026-11-22 14:50:26
Updated
2026-11-22 14:50:26
Yonhap News Agency

[Financial News] A court has ruled that a tax assessment was lawful after tax authorities imposed additional gift tax using as the fair market value the actual transaction price of an apartment in a neighboring building in the same complex that was sold within two years before the gift—even though the recipient had reported the tax on the gifted apartment based on its publicly announced price.
According to legal sources on the 22nd, the Seoul Administrative Court's Administrative Division 6, presided over by Chief Judge Na Jin-yi, ruled against A in a lawsuit seeking to overturn a gift tax assessment filed against the head of the Gwanak Tax Office.
On May 18, 2022, A received as a gift from A's father an apartment on Hoam-ro in Gwanak-gu, Seoul. On the 24th of that month, A reported and paid gift tax of 63.05 million won, calculating the value of the gifted property based on the previous year's publicly announced apartment price of 425 million won.
However, the Gwanak Tax Office found a case in which a unit with the same floor area in a neighboring building in the same apartment complex had been sold for 730 million won about six months before the gift date. After review by the assessment review committee of the Seoul Regional Tax Office, the tax authorities recognized the apartment in the neighboring building as “similar property” under the Inheritance Tax and Gift Tax Act and applied the sale price of 730 million won as the fair market value of A's apartment.
The gift tax came to 78,567,640 won, about 15.51 million won more than the amount originally reported. A challenged the assessment before the Tax Tribunal, but after the petition was dismissed, filed an administrative lawsuit.
A's side argued that the taxation was unlawful. Under the former Enforcement Decree of the Inheritance Tax and Gift Tax Act, when a gift tax base has been reported, the period generally recognized for determining fair market value runs from six months before the valuation date (the date of the gift) to three months after it. A argued that the sale of the apartment used for comparison took place more than six months before the gift date and therefore could not be deemed its fair market value.
A also argued that the gifted apartment and the apartment used for comparison could not be considered similar properties because they were in different buildings and on different floors, and the buildings had different layouts, with 14 units per floor in one and five in the other. There had also been price fluctuations between the sale date and the gift date.
The court sided with the tax authorities. It ruled that even if a sale fell outside the period “from six months before the valuation date to the filing date,” a sale of similar property within “two years before the valuation date” could be included in the fair market value after review by the assessment review committee.
The court also found that the requirements for similar property were met under the relevant enforcement regulations: the two apartments were in the same apartment complex, had the same exclusive residential area, and had the same publicly announced apartment price of 462 million won on the valuation date. It also ruled that the difference in building and floor was not meaningful, as the units were on similar floors in neighboring buildings, and that there was no basis to find a significant difference in sunlight, views, actual transaction frequency or prices.
The argument that market prices had fluctuated was also rejected. The interval between the sale date and the gift date was about six months and 20 days, very close to the statutory valuation period. In addition, another unit in the same building and on the same floor as A's gifted apartment, with the same exclusive area, had also been contracted for sale at 730 million won.
The court also cited official statistics. According to Korea Real Estate Board data, the monthly apartment sale price index for Gwanak-gu was virtually unchanged, at 104.88 in October 2021 and 104.87 in May 2022. The monthly sale price index for Gwanak-gu from KB Real Estate likewise showed no significant change, moving from 99.010 to 100.354.
[email protected] Lee Chang-hun Reporter