Why Did the Tax Accountant Exam’s Top Scorer Apologize on Their Lawyer’s YouTube Channel? [Everyday Life That Became a Case: Attorney Won Hee-young]
- Input
- 2026-11-22 08:00:00
- Updated
- 2026-11-22 08:00:04

[Financial News] 1.7 million views and 15,000 likes within 24 hours of its release.
This is a video in which the top-ranked candidate in the 63rd Tax Accountant Exam apologizes to other examinees on the YouTube channel of a lawyer they hired. Posted on November 15, the video became the most-viewed video ever on the lawyer’s channel in just one day. The candidate admitted to cheating in both the first and second stages of the exam by using electronic devices and generative artificial intelligence (AI). They had already submitted a written statement of self-surrender to the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency. There was reason to apologize directly to other examinees. What I wonder is why the apology had to take place on the lawyer’s YouTube channel.
Would I Have Advised Them to Turn Themselves In If I Were Their Lawyer?
In my previous column, I looked at whether a successful candidate’s cellphone could be searched and seized based solely on their score report. Unusually high scores alone are not enough to prove cheating. But if a client sitting across from me had confessed to actually using electronic devices and AI, I, too, would have advised them to turn themselves in. With the College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT) approaching, even the government announced it would take a strict stance against exam cheating. In these circumstances, it is itself a heavy burden for an individual to deny all the allegations and hold out.
If they bought a device, purchase records may remain; if they asked AI questions during the exam, the exchanges from that time may still be available. If those records later match the answers, the client would have to explain not only how they cheated but also why they had given false explanations until then. Under Article 52(1) of the Criminal Act, a court may reduce or waive the punishment of someone who voluntarily surrenders to an investigative agency. But there is no requirement to make one’s name known to the public or record the circumstances of the offense on video.
Where Would Have Been a Good Place to Apologize to Other Examinees?
The lawyer introduced the video as one in which the successful candidate personally disclosed the facts and apologized. The candidate had previously made false statements in an account of their exam success and in interviews, and continued to deny cheating even after suspicions emerged. An examinee who had believed that account would have wanted to hear directly from its author which parts were false.
If I had discussed how to apologize with the candidate, I would have advised them to post an apology in the same place where they had shared their account of passing the exam. That way, they could explain in their own words which parts were untrue to the people who had trusted and read the study methods the candidate had written. The lawyer could also issue a brief statement to the media announcing the candidate’s self-surrender. Even after apologizing that way, the candidate could submit any remaining devices and materials to the police, as the lawyer said, and explain the circumstances of the cheating to the body administering the exam.
Were YouTube Earnings an Upfront Fee or a Success Fee?
In 2015, the Supreme Court sitting en banc held that agreements for success fees in criminal cases entered into after that ruling were invalid. The reason was that tying lawyers’ fees to the outcome of an investigation or trial could undermine trust in the criminal justice system. This January, a civil appellate panel of the Seoul Central District Court ruled that an agreement providing for a success fee contingent on a final acquittal was valid and ordered the client to pay the agreed fee. Both rulings addressed the validity of agreements under which a lawyer receives payment depending on the outcome of a case.
YouTube revenue does not come with such a condition. For example, if the channel earns 5 won in advertising revenue per view, 1.7 million views would bring in 8.5 million won. What disposition the client receives is not a condition for the revenue to be generated. Even if there were no revenue, people who came to watch the apology would see the name of the lawyer handling the case in the channel name.
If That Apology Stays on the Lawyer’s Channel
It is not known whether the candidate or the lawyer first suggested appearing in the video. If the candidate wanted to apologize in their own voice, that wish should also be respected. If I were to suggest that a client appear on my channel, I would first make clear what benefit I might gain from the video. Most clients who entrust a criminal case to a lawyer are in an extremely vulnerable state. To such clients, a lawyer’s words become a ray of hope and light. That is why I think carefully before making any suggestion to a client in a criminal case.
Even if the client starts doing something else a few years from now, someone may search their name and find the apology they made that day. If the client then asks for the video to be taken down, I could delete the original from my channel. But I could not promise to remove copies that other people had uploaded in the meantime. The client should be able to decide whether to appear knowing that, too. The day after the video was posted, the lawyer re-edited the original and also used it for YouTube Shorts.
If there had been no YouTube channel, would I still have advised this client to stand in front of a camera? What I want most is for the client to forget this difficult period and return to a peaceful life. People involved in criminal cases live in hell, whether they are perpetrators or victims. To escape that hell and recover on their own, they desperately need to forget. It is hard for me to recommend a way of apologizing that could leave their apology on the internet for the rest of their life.
[About the Author]
Attorney Won Hee-young is a former reporter for Financial News and currently handles criminal cases at YK Law Firm. A graduate of Ewha Womans University, Won earned a master’s degree in media and communication from Seoul National University and graduated from Ewha Womans University School of Law. Won examines how ordinary life can lead to legal disputes and explains the key issues that shape case outcomes, along with practical ways to respond.
[email protected] Lee Hwan-joo Reporter