Saturday, November 21, 2026

If It's Hard to Voice a Different Opinion in a Meeting... Cha Seok-yong's 'Hasim' [The Working Professional's Weekend Reading Room]

Input
2026-11-21 10:00:00
Updated
2026-11-21 10:00:03
The cover of Cha Seok-yong's memoir, “Hasim: The Beautiful Showers That Fell Upon My Life.” Provided by Open Books
Two days before the final bid for the 2007 acquisition of Korea Coca-Cola Bottling, then-LG Household & Health Care President Cha Seok-yong received word that the bid would have to be raised by 40 billion won to beat a rival. Cha wondered whether his confidence that he could revive the business had become an obsession. He told the late Koo Bon-moo, chairman of LG Group, that he intended to abandon the acquisition.This anecdote appears in the memoir “Hasim: The Beautiful Showers That Fell Upon My Life” (Open Books), published on the 5th of last month by Cha Seok-yong, former vice chairman of LG Household & Health Care. After working at P&G Korea and Haitai Confectionery & Foods, the author led LG Household & Health Care for 18 years. In total, he spent 28 years as a chief executive at various companies. The book recounts decisions he made at pivotal moments in business and advice he gave executives and employees while in office.■ Information That Changes Management DecisionsAccording to the book, the company being acquired had been running at a loss for years. The next day, Chairman Koo parked his car at the end of Mapo Bridge and told Cha that confidence and determination to revive the business were important. Cha resumed negotiations with Coca-Cola. They worked out the terms until after 10 p.m., and he submitted the final bid the following day.
LG Household & Health Care signed an agreement with the seller, Coca-Cola Amatil, that August and completed the acquisition on October 24. The total purchase price announced by the company at the time was 385.3 billion won, including liabilities. Korea Coca-Cola Bottling changed its name to Coca-Cola Beverage the following year.
Because Cha, who had been driving the deal, expressed his intention to withdraw before the bid, there was time to reconsider the acquisition plan. To continue negotiations, they had to assess whether they could cover the additional cost and how they might revive the loss-making business after acquiring it. In the workplace, too, the person pushing a plan must be able to propose stopping it so that a decision can be changed when circumstances shift.
How costs changed is also information needed to make a decision. When the author worked at P&G, the fragrance sprayer at the New York plant was bent to reduce the amount dispensed. The union was trying to lower costs after headquarters considered relocating the plant, citing the cost burden. In such a case, a report should include not only the savings but also which raw materials were reduced and what impact that might have on the product.
Cha Seok-yong, author of “Hasim” and former vice chairman of LG Household & Health Care. Provided by LG Household & Health Care
■ Conditions for Meetings That Hear Dissenting ViewsThe latter part of the book, under “CEO MESSAGE,” includes 16 pieces the author sent to executives and employees from 2005 to 2020. He urges them to share bad news promptly—the worse the news, the sooner it should be reported—and to distinguish confirmed facts from opinions. In particular, he emphasizes asking questions with evidence, regardless of rank, when they have doubts about a decision.
For example, suppose 10 units of a product about to be launched are tested, and the power shuts off in two of them. The test results are confirmed facts; proposing a delay to the launch is the person in charge's recommendation. First, report the conditions under which the power shut off and what has yet to be verified. When asking to adjust the schedule, also specify the time and staffing needed for additional tests.
If it is difficult to speak up in a meeting, you can briefly write down the facts confirmed before a decision and your concerns, then ask for them to be reviewed. You can also send the supporting materials.
A leader who receives the report can set criteria for which test results would warrant delaying the launch, and decide who will conduct a recheck and when it will be reviewed. If the decision is to launch as scheduled, the leader should explain the reason to the team. By contrast, holding the person who reported the problem responsible before anything else can delay the next report.
The “Hasim” the author describes is an attitude of humbling oneself and being willing to learn. Before your next meeting, ask yourself: What is the basis for my judgment, and what facts, if confirmed, would make me change my decision?
[email protected] Jang In-seo Reporter