Friday, November 20, 2026

‘SM Stock Manipulation Allegations’: Kakao Founder Kim Beom-soo Also Acquitted on Appeal... Court: ‘Defense Buying Must Be Interpreted Strictly’

Input
2026-11-20 11:01:30
Updated
2026-11-20 11:01:30
Kim Beom-soo, founder of Kakao Corp. and head of the Future Initiative Center, who was indicted on stock price manipulation charges during the acquisition of SM Entertainment and acquitted at trial, is attending the sentencing hearing in his appeal at the Seoul High Court in Seocho District, Seoul, on the 20th. Newsis

[Financial News] Kakao Corp. founder Kim Beom-soo (head of the Future Initiative Center), who was indicted on charges of artificially manipulating SM Entertainment’s share price to obstruct rival HYBE’s tender offer during the acquisition of SM Entertainment, was acquitted on appeal, following his acquittal at trial.
The Seoul High Court’s Criminal Division 4-1 (Presiding Judges Kim In-gyeong, Seong Ji-yong, and Jeon Ji-won) dismissed all of the prosecution’s appeals at a hearing on the morning of the 20th for the appellate cases against defendants including Kim, Bae Jae-hyun, Kakao Corp., and Kakao Entertainment Corp., who were indicted on charges of violating the Capital Markets Act. The Kakao-side defendants, including Kim, remained acquitted on appeal, as they had at trial.
However, Ji Chang-bae, head of One Asia Partners, who was also indicted, was sentenced at trial to three years in prison, suspended for four years, for misappropriating fund assets for personal use (embezzlement under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes), and the lower court’s sentence was upheld.
The appellate panel made clear that establishing “a series of transactions for the purpose of fixing or stabilizing market prices,” prohibited under Article 176(3) of the Capital Markets Act, requires artificial manipulation as a prerequisite.
The panel stressed that “every transaction in the securities market has the potential, by itself, to affect market prices,” and that “it would be unjust to recognize a series of transactions as an objective element of the offense without limiting the manner of conduct, as that would result in punishing subjective intent alone.”
In particular, it recognized ordinary share purchases during hostile mergers and acquisitions (M&A) as a broad means of defending management control. The panel explained, “In a tender offer or hostile M&A situation, it is permissible for the target company or a competing company to make on-market purchases through ordinary means to secure a friendly stake, as this constitutes a common method of defending management control.”
The panel stressed that “it is unjust to punish every purchase merely because on-market buying could affect market prices, even in the absence of artificial manipulation,” and that “the law must be interpreted strictly, as otherwise the scope of punishment could expand without limit.”
The prosecution viewed funds from One Asia Partners (218 high-price buy orders, 141 orders to exhaust available supply, and 4 closing-price intervention orders) and funds from Kakao Corp. (132 high-price buy orders, 55 orders to exhaust available supply, and 3 closing-price intervention orders) as means of artificially raising and supporting the share price. The panel, however, found that the orders did not exhibit the characteristics of high-price buying, volume exhaustion, or closing-price intervention associated with market manipulation.
The panel said, “The evidence submitted by the prosecution alone is insufficient to establish a purpose of fixing or stabilizing market prices through artificial manipulation, or a conspiracy,” adding that “a violation of the large-shareholding disclosure requirement (the 5% rule), premised on a conspiracy among Bae Jae-hyun, Ji Chang-bae, and Kim Beom-soo, likewise cannot be found to constitute an offense.”
The sentence for Representative Ji’s violation of the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes—the only charge on which he was convicted at trial—was also upheld. The panel dismissed the argument, saying, “Breach of trust in the course of business and embezzlement in the course of business are both property crimes based on a relationship of trust. They differ only in their legal characterization, have the same nature, and are prescribed in the same statutory provision with no difference in severity of punishment; therefore, this cannot be grounds for overturning the judgment.”
Kim and the others were indicted on charges that, in February 2023, during the acquisition of SM Entertainment, they conspired with private equity fund manager One Asia Partners and others to make large-scale on-market purchases in order to thwart HYBE’s tender offer of 120,000 won and keep SM Entertainment’s share price above the offer price.
Earlier, the Seoul Southern District Court’s Criminal Division 15 (Presiding Judge Yang Hwan-seung) acquitted them at the first-trial sentencing hearing in October last year, citing the lack of credibility of testimony from a key witness and differences from typical market-manipulation orders. The prosecution sought a 15-year prison sentence and a fine of 500 million won for Kim at the appellate court’s final hearing, but the second-trial panel also concluded that the first-trial acquittal was justified.
[email protected] Lee Chang-hoon Reporter