Friday, November 20, 2026

“Hate the Sin, but Do Not Hate the Person” ... Seoul National University Professor Offers Blunt Criticism Amid Lee Jin-woo Controversy

Input
2026-11-20 04:00:00
Updated
2026-11-20 04:00:02
Lee Jin-woo, who got a perfect score on the LEET. Photo: Yonhap News

[Financial News] A Seoul National University professor expressed concern about the online culture of excessively criticizing specific individuals, as Lee Jin-woo, who was known for scoring a perfect mark on the Law Education Eligibility Test (LEET), was found in cardiac arrest. The view is that people should be held strictly accountable for wrongdoing, but the person involved should not be deprived of the chance to rebuild their life.
Shin Jae-yong, a professor at Seoul National University's School of Business and author of “Fair Compensation,” posted on the workplace networking service Remember Connect on the 19th, sharing his thoughts on the controversy surrounding Lee and the social response to it.
Lee was found in cardiac arrest that day at a lodging facility in Gangdong-gu, Seoul.
Professor Shin referred to Lee's book “Brain Axel” and said, “It's truly heartbreaking.” Shin expressed sympathy for the situation Lee had faced and raised concerns about the criticism that continued even after the controversy. He added, “I was taught that while we may hate the sin, we must not hate the person.”
Professor Shin also mentioned the case of Kim Min-ji, author of “Wise Parents Keep a Reasonable Distance,” who faced controversy over alleged fabrication of academic credentials and an endorsement in June last year.
Citing the case of Kim, who died after the related controversy, Shin said, “A similar thing has happened again in just over a year.”
Professor Shin explained that the two shared the fact that they published books and attracted public attention by foregrounding their outstanding academic credentials and test scores.
Shin said that “both used the top-tier academic credentials and test scores coveted by the public as the books' central sales pitch,” and criticized how the publishing industry and online communities abruptly changed their attitudes toward the two after the controversies arose.
Professor Shin noted that both faced demands for explanations and verification as allegations spread, and said, “I hope this doesn't happen again.”
Professor Shin also took a critical view of the public, the publishing industry and the media for judging celebrities primarily by their academic backgrounds and careers.
Shin argued that people should reflect on the tendency to boost an author's popularity by focusing on their credentials rather than the book's content, then immediately cut ties with and criticize them when suspicions arise.
Professor Shin clarified that he was not arguing that people should be exempt from responsibility for wrongdoing.
Shin said, “Falsifying one's résumé and academic credentials and securing personal gain through fraud and falsehood deserve criticism,” but emphasized that no matter what wrongdoing a person has committed, they should not be criticized in a way that rejects their entire life.
Shin went on to argue that society should reflect on the conditions that allow these kinds of controversies to recur.
Shin described it as “a thoroughly Korean, so very Korean, situation” and said that the social isolation of people who have done wrong should not be allowed to happen again.
Professor Shin said, “I hope people will be captivated by creators' content and substance, rather than their résumés and academic credentials,” adding, “People should be held strictly accountable for wrongdoing, but I hope we will leave a path for those who have done wrong to rebuild their lives.”
Shin said, “I hope we can have a society that neither overvalues a person's worth based on their academic background and résumé nor turns one person's wrongdoing into a rejection of their entire existence,” adding, “I hope this will not be a society where anyone has to pay for their mistakes with their life.”
After recently facing allegations of cheating on an exam using generative AI, Lee announced that he would demonstrate his ability by solving questions from the Korean-language section of the College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT) in real time.
However, Lee did not appear at the venue for the public verification scheduled for the morning of the 19th, and contact with him was lost. The YouTube livestream hosted by the private academy organizing the verification reportedly drew about 400,000 viewers.
After receiving a report that morning expressing concern for Lee's safety, police were trying to locate him when they found him in cardiac arrest at around 1:12 p.m. at a lodging facility in Gangdong-gu, Seoul.
Lee had previously published “Brain Axel,” a book about his CSAT results and study experiences. The previous day, a criminal complaint had reportedly been filed alleging obstruction of business and other offenses, and a police investigation had begun.※ If you are struggling with depression or other difficult concerns, or have a family member or acquaintance going through such difficulties, you can speak with a professional 24 hours a day by calling the Suicide Prevention Counseling Hotline at 109.[email protected] Han Seung-gon Reporter