Friday, November 20, 2026

Could the State Also Be Liable if It Fails to Prevent Cheating? [CSAT Amid AI Cheating Concerns]

Input
2026-11-19 18:26:33
Updated
2026-11-19 22:15:41
A test taker places an electronic device in an envelope at Yongsan High School in Yongsan District, Seoul, on the morning of the 19th, when the 2027 College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT) was held. Joint Photo Coverage Team

With supervision against cheating using artificial intelligence (AI) strengthened for this year’s College Scholastic Ability Test, whether the state can be held legally liable if an exam authority fails to prevent cheating has emerged as a key issue. The debate follows the recent case of the top scorer on the tax accountant exam, whose AI-assisted cheating was not detected at the exam site and came to light after the person confessed. Legal experts say the focus should be less on the failure to detect cheating itself and more on whether preventive measures at the time were adequate and whether actual harm occurred.
Hyun Min-seok, a lawyer at YK Law Firm, said on the 19th, “A damages claim itself is possible,” while emphasizing that “liability is not established simply because cheating was not detected.” The point is that a causal link must be established between inadequate preventive measures, the failure to detect cheating and a particular candidate’s failure.
Wi Jong-wook, a lawyer at D&A LLC, said, “If the required oversight procedures were not put in place even after a new method became known, there may be grounds for liability,” adding, “If a specific examinee suffered harm by failing, it may be possible to hold the state liable for its supervisory responsibility under the State Compensation Act.”
Lee Je-nam, a lawyer at Daeryun Law Firm, also noted, “If the previous oversight methods were still in place for the second-stage tax accountant exam on July 18, after smart-glasses cheating was detected in other national qualification exams in May and June, that could be contested.”
Last October, the Supreme Court overturned and remanded a lower court ruling in a state compensation case over grading errors on the tax accountant exam, saying that a violation of internal guidelines alone does not immediately establish liability for damages. Although grading errors and negligence in supervision are different matters, the ruling is considered a precedent worth noting because it assesses the illegality of state agencies’ actions separately from liability for damages.
Choi Seung-hwan, a lawyer at Barun Law LLC, said, “If reasonable preventive and supervisory measures required at the time were neglected despite a known risk, there may be grounds to find a breach of the duty of care.” He cautioned, however, that “a high score by itself is not evidence of cheating, and whether the law requires such post-exam verification must be determined based on the specific circumstances.”
Providing remedies for affected examinees is also difficult. This year, 722 candidates passed the tax accountant exam overall; the 712 successful candidates who took all subjects in the second stage alone already exceed the minimum of 700. Canceling the result of one candidate who passed by cheating does not automatically mean that the next-ranked candidate passes.
Oh Jeong-ik, a lawyer on the TIF team at One Law Partners, explained, “There are legal grounds for seeking to hold the state liable, but as a practical matter, it would be difficult for state liability for damages to be recognized under the law.” He said claimants must do more than allege negligence in supervision: they must prove the individual examinee’s harm and the causal link.

[email protected] Yoo Seon-jun Reporter