U.S.-China-Russia Trilateral Talks... 'A Second Yalta' or 'A Grandiose Photo Op'?
- Input
- 2026-11-19 17:02:08
- Updated
- 2026-11-19 17:08:50

On the morning of the 19th, after attending the APEC summit at the Shenzhen International Exchange Center in China, President Donald Trump held a brief meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin. Standing beside Putin, Trump said, “We are looking forward to the meeting. We have had a very good relationship for many years, and we have known each other for a long time.” He added, “There could be many great outcomes from this meeting,” stressing that it would at least establish a starting point.
The White House initially announced that there would be no U.S.-Russia summit during the APEC summit, but a face-to-face meeting was ultimately arranged amid Russia's active push, according to reports. During the brief U.S.-Russia meeting that day, Putin, who is notorious for keeping others waiting, was spotted arriving at the venue first and waiting for Trump, drawing attention.
After the brief U.S.-Russia meeting, Trump also held a U.S.-China summit. Trump said that he and Xi Jinping shared the same views on issues including ensuring the transport of crude oil through the Strait of Hormuz and preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. On the war in Ukraine, he also said, “The United States and China both want to help Russia and Ukraine. We hope the war will end.”
He also said that U.S.-China economic relations had improved considerably over the past year and a half. Trump said, “When I visited Beijing this past May, we established a trade committee, which brought greater balance to a relationship that had been very unbalanced,” adding, “We made it a fair relationship, and that's all we want.”
There are differing predictions about the trilateral U.S.-China-Russia summit that will follow the U.S.-Russia and U.S.-China summits. Some worry that the great powers could redraw their spheres of influence while excluding parties to the conflicts, such as Ukraine; others predict that the three countries' competing interests will make it difficult to reach concrete agreements.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy previously said last month, in reference to efforts to arrange a trilateral summit, “I really don't want this to become a ‘second, third or fourth Yalta’ that redistributes influence.” The Yalta Conference was held in February 1945, when the leaders of the United States, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union met to discuss the postwar order in Europe and arrangements following the end of World War II. It symbolizes the power politics in which the fate of smaller countries is often decided through negotiations among great powers without the participation of the countries concerned. In fact, European leaders decided to meet separately in Berlin, Germany, that day amid concerns that this could become a “second Yalta Conference.”
Others say those concerns are unfounded, since the three leaders have major differences on issues including China's nuclear weapons. For example, Trump is hoping for discussions on nuclear arms control, but Xi, whose country has fewer nuclear warheads, is reportedly opposed to taking on arms-control obligations on the same terms as the United States and Russia.
It is also worth noting that the Yalta Conference lasted eight days, while this trilateral summit is expected to last just over an hour. Given the difference in duration alone, some predict the meeting will amount to little more than a “grandiose photo op” capturing the three countries' “strongmen” gathered in one place.
A senior Blue House official said that day, “First of all, China, the host of APEC, is itself a country that considers itself a victim of the Yalta Conference,” adding, “The United States, China and Russia don't all think alike now, so those three countries aren't in the same position as the great powers that gathered at Yalta in the past, for example.” He continued, “The United States, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union may have had different views on the world order after World War II, but they had in common that they fought against Germany. There isn't that kind of common ground now.”
[email protected] Hong Chae-wan Reporter