Court Upholds Cancellation of Saemangeum Airport Plan on Appeal... “Bird-Strike Risk Was Not Assessed During Site Selection”
- Input
- 2026-11-18 15:05:00
- Updated
- 2026-11-18 15:05:00

On the afternoon of the 18th, the Seoul High Court’s Administrative Division 4-2, comprising presiding judges Lee Gwang-man, Kwangseop Moon and Park Yeon-uk, dismissed MOLIT’s appeal in a suit seeking cancellation of the master plan, brought against the minister by 1,296 people, including a plaintiff identified only by the surname Kim. Jeonbuk State and Korea Airports Corporation (KAC) participated in the appeal as supporting intervenors on MOLIT’s side.
The panel ruled that “the public interest associated with development presupposes that an airport can be operated safely,” adding that “aviation safety is a public interest that must be given particular consideration when selecting an airport site, because even a single aircraft-bird collision can cause serious harm to many people’s lives and physical well-being, as well as to property.”
The panel went on to conclude that “the defendant appears to have given disproportionate weight to the benefits of development without reviewing and assessing the public interests in protecting life and physical safety and preserving the environment to a degree commensurate with their importance,” and that “the comparison and balancing of the relevant public interests lacked legitimacy and objectivity.” The court found the plan unlawful because of flaws in the balancing of interests, reaching the same conclusion as the first-instance court did last September.
The panel found that bird-strike risks must be considered from the site-selection stage. It cited MOLIT’s “Standards for Reducing the Risk of Collisions with Birds and Other Wildlife,” which require collision risks to be assessed in advance and measures to minimize them to be prepared when an airport is built, as well as the fact that the Convention on International Civil Aviation, ratified in 1952, has the same force as domestic law. The panel said, “Rather than selecting a site first and considering afterward how to manage bird-strike risks, authorities must examine from the site-selection stage whether those risks can be avoided or sufficiently reduced.”
A 2019 commissioned report received by MOLIT screened 13 candidate sites and selected the current project site as the optimal location. Although the report said it had ensured fairness by using International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) standards, the panel noted that it “did not assess at all the bird-strike risks that the ICAO assessment criteria specifically emphasize.” It found that some review had been conducted as part of the strategic environmental impact assessment, but that it had not been substantively reflected in the site selection.
An assessment using MOLIT’s model for reviewing sites for new airports found that the project site’s bird-strike risk was far higher than that of other airports in South Korea. MOLIT reassessed the site using a model for operating airports and narrowed the assessment range to 5 km, but the panel found that approach unreasonable. The main basis for considering the risk low was the operating experience of nearby Gunsan Airport.
The effectiveness of the mitigation measures was also not established. The project site lies on the East Asian–Australasian Flyway, and at least 31 species of legally protected birds are found in the surrounding area. The panel found a considerable likelihood that implementing the mitigation measures would conflict with regulations protecting legally protected species and with some provisions of the Saemangeum Master Plan. The Korea Environment Institute and the Korea Heritage Service, among others, also raised this issue in response to factual inquiries during the appeal. Seocheon Tidal Flat, about 7 km from the project site, is both a wetland protection area and a UNESCO World Natural Heritage site.
The panel acknowledged the need to revitalize the Jeonbuk economy and that the project was essential to the Saemangeum Airport Economic Zone Project. The ruling also noted the constitutional duty under Article 123 to foster regional economies and the long-standing aspirations of Jeonbuk residents and businesspeople. However, in balancing the interests, the panel pointed to Article 35, Paragraph 1 of the Constitution, which obliges the state and its citizens to work to preserve the environment.
The first-instance ruling was also upheld: it recognized only the three plaintiffs living near the project site as having standing to sue under the Airport Noise Prevention Act and dismissed the remaining claims. The appeals by the plaintiffs whose claims had been dismissed were also dismissed. MOLIT argued that cancellation could not be sought on grounds of illegality unrelated to noise, but the panel rejected that argument. The panel said, “Germany’s Administrative Court Procedure Act and Japan’s Administrative Case Litigation Act contain provisions along the lines of the defendant’s argument, but South Korea’s Administrative Litigation Act provides otherwise,” adding that Supreme Court of Korea precedents also allow courts to review grounds for a plan’s illegality in their entirety.
Earlier, two applications filed by some of the plaintiffs seeking to halt administrative procedures related to the project until a final ruling on the merits were, respectively, denied and dismissed in March. The ruling states that the same issues continue to be raised in the environmental impact assessment process underway since the master plan was announced. The master plan, announced by MOLIT on June 30, 2022, will be canceled once the ruling becomes final. The lawsuit was filed in September of that year. The government has pursued the project with completion targeted for 2028 and opening for 2029.
[email protected] Kim Dong-gyu Reporter