Gangnam, Seocho See Rise in Legal Inquiries on Reconstruction Levies; Calculation Standards and Constitutionality at Issue
- Input
- 2026-11-18 07:53:20
- Updated
- 2026-11-18 07:53:20

[Financial News] Inquiries are increasing about the appropriateness of calculating levies under the Reconstruction Excess Profit Recovery System and about legal response options, particularly in major reconstruction complexes in Gangnam and Seocho, Seoul. The constitutionality of imposing levies on unrealized gains, as well as methods for assessing housing values and the scope of recognized development costs, is being raised as a legal issue, drawing attention to the possibility of future disputes.
Inquiries to Bae, Kim & Lee and others on the 18th found that interest and inquiries about levy calculation standards and legal response options have recently increased, particularly at major complexes in Gangnam and Seocho where reconstruction levies are expected to be imposed.
The reconstruction levy under the Reconstruction Excess Profit Recovery System recoups part of the excess profits generated by a reconstruction project. The levy is calculated based on the excess profit after excluding normal increases in housing prices and other factors from the gains generated by reconstruction. It is calculated by deducting the housing value at the start of the project, normal housing price increases, development costs and other items from the housing value at the end of the project.
The amount of the levy may vary depending on the standards used to assess housing values and how much of the costs incurred during the project are recognized. In other words, even for the same reconstruction project, the final levy may differ depending on the calculation standards and scope of recognition applied to each item.
From methods of calculating housing values to development costs, levy calculations are at issue
Bae, Kim & Lee analyzed that the assessment standards and scope of recognition for each item in the levy calculation process could become major legal issues.
In particular, if different methods are used to calculate housing values at the start and end of a project, the question of whether this creates an imbalance in the levy calculation may arise. Development costs are also a factor affecting the levy amount, as it matters which items can be recognized as eligible for deduction.
The issue may go beyond whether the levy is high or low and extend to whether the assessment methods and cost-recognition standards applied in the calculation process were appropriate. If levies are actually imposed in the future, reconstruction associations or their members may examine the basis for the calculations and challenge the legality of the relevant standards, the firm said.
The constitutionality of the system itself is also being raised as a legal issue. One matter under review is whether delegating to subordinate regulations matters such as the method for assessing housing values—which significantly affects levy calculations—violates the principle of statutory reservation and the prohibition on blanket delegation.
It may also be argued that applying a statutory levy rate of up to 50% to unrealized gains violates the principle of proportionality. The point is that it is necessary to examine whether imposing a levy before gains have been realized through an actual sale places an excessive restriction on property rights.
However, in 2019, the Constitutional Court ruled that the reconstruction levy system and some provisions on calculating housing values were constitutional. The firm said it would therefore be important in future discussions of constitutionality to distinguish the issues addressed in the existing ruling from newly raised issues.
Whether members excluded from eligibility for a levy reduction based on long-term ownership face an excessive burden is also cited as a legal issue. Since each member’s burden may vary depending on whether they qualify for a reduction, the appropriateness of the relevant standards may be called into question.
Submitting comments before imposition, administrative litigation afterward; system reform also pursued
Bae, Kim & Lee said that opinions pointing to unreasonable levy calculations and problems with the system itself are being raised at complexes where the imposition of reconstruction levies is being pursued.
Attorney Moon Seong-ho, co-head of the reconstruction levy response task force at Bae, Kim & Lee, said, “At complexes where the imposition of reconstruction levies is being pursued recently, many opinions have been raised about unreasonable levy calculations and problems with the system itself.” He predicted, “Many disputes are expected once levies are actually imposed.”
Legal responses fall into two stages: before and after a levy is imposed. Before imposition, parties can submit comments on the calculation to check whether assessment standards and the scope of recognized development costs, among other things, have been appropriately reflected. After a levy is actually imposed, they can challenge the legality of the decision through an administrative appeal or administrative litigation.
If the constitutionality of the law itself is at issue, one option is to seek a referral for constitutional review of the statute in related litigation. However, such a review is a procedure in which a court refers the matter to the Constitutional Court after determining that the constitutionality of the law is a prerequisite to deciding the case.
Bae, Kim & Lee said that solutions through system reform are also needed, in addition to legal responses in individual cases. The reason is that problems with levy calculation standards or the reduction system may be difficult to resolve solely by challenging individual decisions. Attorney Moon stressed, “It is also necessary to pursue a legislative solution by recommending system improvements to the government and the National Assembly.”
[email protected] Yoo Seon-jun Reporter