Illegal Gambling Operation Involving Around 1.23 Trillion Won... Supreme Court: “Proceeds From Sites Not Named in the Indictment Cannot Be Forfeited”
- Input
- 2026-11-17 14:03:58
- Updated
- 2026-11-17 14:03:58

According to legal sources on the 17th, the Supreme Court of Korea’s First Division, with Justice Cheon Dae-yeob as the justice in charge, on the 27th of last month overturned the portion of the lower court’s ruling concerning Shin Hee-seong and remanded the case to the Changwon District Court. The forfeiture amount, which had been reduced to 18,433,058,541 won in the second trial, will be reconsidered. The six-year prison sentence was also overturned because the charge of opening a gambling place and the other counts of conviction were treated as concurrent offenses and received a single sentence.
Shin was indicted on charges of operating three illegal gambling websites with Song In-seok and others at an apartment in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, from April 7, 2020, to January 20 of last year. The sites let users bet on casino games such as baccarat and slots. Using 166 gambling accounts for deposits and withdrawals, they received transfers totaling 1,230,989,660,000 won in about 2.43 million transactions, credited users with game money, and paid out 1,013,225,360,000 won. Shin acknowledged receiving 25% of the proceeds.
The issue was how to calculate the amount subject to forfeiture. In December last year, the Changwon District Court, the court of first instance, found credible a ledger of deposit and withdrawal records submitted by an informant and a settlement file on a USB drive seized from Shin’s residence. It ordered forfeiture of 37,680,080,000 won, applying Shin’s 25% share to the difference between the deposits and payouts. In July this year, the second-instance court deducted distributor commissions and the so-called “al-gap” costs from the total operating proceeds, then applied 25%, reducing the amount to 18,433,050,000 won.
The Supreme Court took issue with that ledger. The indictment specified only three sites, but the case record included evidence supporting the claim that Shin had also been partly involved in operating another casino site during the same period. The court said that “even if the defendant actually operated all four of the above gambling sites, the criminal proceeds that may be forfeited in this case must in principle be limited to those from sites for which charges were brought and guilt established”—that is, the operating proceeds of the three sites.
The court also pointed to the possibility that the accounts had been mixed. It said some deposit and withdrawal accounts were used across multiple sites, and that funds on hand were not strictly separated by site, making it “difficult to rule out the possibility that they were transferred between or shared among the sites.” It added that the ledgers could also include transactions from sites that were not indicted or transfers of funds between sites.
Under previous rulings, proceeds cannot be forfeited if the criminal proceeds subject to forfeiture cannot be identified; when several people jointly operate a gambling business, only the profits that actually accrued to each person may be forfeited individually. The court said that the criminal proceeds Shin actually obtained through the operation of the three indicted sites should have been identified from the total operating proceeds of each site he ran, and that only those proceeds should have been forfeited.
[email protected] Kim Dong-gyu Reporter