“Mom Cried All Night”: Wife Asks Husband to Guarantee 100 Million Won for Brother-in-Law Who Failed Twice [What Do You Think?]
- Input
- 2026-11-17 09:32:45
- Updated
- 2026-11-17 09:32:45

[Financial News] “Mr. Kim, have we ever asked you for anything before? Just help us this once.”A, who is in his third year of marriage, recently received this call from his mother-in-law and sat in his car for a long time. She was asking him to guarantee a business loan needed by his brother-in-law to open a cafe. The amount was close to 100 million won.
A husband who does not dislike his in-laws but feels uneasy about acting as a guarantor
When he first heard about it, A said, “I’ll think about it,” and stepped away. But after seeing the business plan his brother-in-law sent, he felt even more uneasy. It was filled with figures that seemed unrealistic to A, including projected monthly sales of 10 million won in the first month.
What troubled him most was his brother-in-law’s past. He had opened two businesses before, and both had closed within a year. A understood that the losses at the time had been covered with his father-in-law’s retirement pay. When A told his wife he felt uneasy about it, she seemed to understand at first, but the mood soon changed. Remarks such as “Mom cried all night” and “If we don’t help, who will?” continued, weighing on A.
A said, “It’s not that I dislike my in-laws, and I’m grateful for the help they gave us when we were preparing for our wedding.” But he also expressed his concern: “If things go wrong, we could lose our own home too. I don’t know if it’s right to guarantee a loan just because we’re family.”
This account, posted on an online community on the 14th, illustrates the “guarantee dilemma” that often arises among family members. People have long suffered losses after guaranteeing loans for family or acquaintances and having to repay them when the borrowers cannot.
Guarantees between family members do not always end with a simple family dispute. Courts have repeatedly seen cases in which siblings who acted as joint guarantors for one another’s loans disputed the extent of their liability. Experts therefore advise against deciding whether to guarantee a loan simply because a family member has asked.
Especially when guaranteeing a business loan, the decision should be based on whether you could repay the entire loan yourself if the borrower’s business failed. Before acting as a guarantor, you should also check at least the △guarantee amount △guarantee period △debt covered by the guarantee △interest and default interest △scope of the guarantee △amount the financial institution can claim from the guarantor in the event of default.

Joint guarantees have effectively disappeared, and even the remaining exceptions are being considered for abolition
Following the devastating 1997 foreign exchange crisis, the government and financial sector gradually scaled back joint guarantees. In 1999, banks capped guarantees at 10 million to 20 million won per case, and from 2003 they limited the total amount to 50 million to 60 million won. The share of household bank credit loans requiring a joint guarantor fell from 29.4% at the end of 2001 to 11.8% at the end of 2003.
Then, in July 2008, all domestic banks abolished personal joint guarantees for household loans, starting with new loans. In 2012, third-party joint guarantees for business loans by family members, colleagues and others unrelated to corporate management were completely eliminated. From July 2013, new joint guarantees in the secondary financial sector—including savings banks, mutual finance institutions, card companies, capital finance companies and insurers—were prohibited in principle. The Financial Services Commission estimated at the time that 1.55 million joint guarantors and 75 trillion won in guarantees were tied up in the secondary financial sector alone.
In April 2018, public institutions including the Korea Credit Guarantee Fund and the Korea Technology Finance Corporation also abolished joint guarantees they had required from representatives of small and medium-sized enterprise corporations. A few exceptions remain, such as guarantees for second chances and business restarts. Kang Seung-jun, chairman of the Korea Credit Guarantee Fund, said during a National Assembly audit on the 15th of last month that even these exceptions would be considered for abolition.
[email protected] Kim Hee-sun Reporter