Korea Zinc and MBK Clash Even Over the Ruling's Interpretation... 'Permissible Scope' of Defending Management Control at Issue [fn Market Watch]
- Input
- 2026-11-16 15:51:10
- Updated
- 2026-11-16 15:51:10

[Financial News] The dispute over control of Korea Zinc has spilled over into a battle over how to interpret the court's ruling. Youngpoong Corporation and MBK Partners won at first instance in a lawsuit seeking to overturn resolutions passed at last year's annual shareholders' meeting, prompting Korea Zinc to push back, saying the ruling is being interpreted too broadly. How far reciprocal shareholdings may be used to defend management control has emerged as a key issue in the upcoming appeal.
On the 16th, investment banking (IB) industry sources said the 29th Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs on the 12th in a lawsuit filed by Youngpoong Corporation to overturn shareholders' meeting resolutions. Major resolutions passed at the regular shareholders' meeting in March last year—including amendments to the articles of incorporation and the appointment of directors and audit committee members—are subject to cancellation.
Citing the ruling, Youngpoong Corporation and MBK Partners argued that it confirmed the illegality of Korea Zinc executives' use of overseas affiliates Sun Metal Corporation (SMC) and Sun Metal Holdings (SMH) to restrict Youngpoong's voting rights.
They particularly emphasized that the court had pointed to the private use of company assets and a 'breach of directors' duty of loyalty.' They also took issue with the additional share purchase on the day of last year's shareholders' meeting to bring Youngpoong's stake to 10.03%, as well as the circumstances behind the meeting's opening being delayed by 2 hours and 32 minutes. They also raised the possibility of violations of the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act's provisions banning cross-shareholdings and unlawful circumvention.
Korea Zinc, meanwhile, countered that MBK Partners was interpreting the plaintiffs' arguments set out in the ruling as if they were the court's own findings. It says the first-instance ruling has legal flaws, noting that the Supreme Court dismissed Youngpoong's further appeal in a related injunction case this April.
Korea Zinc argued, "Restrictions on voting rights in reciprocal shareholdings must be applied objectively in accordance with statutory requirements," and that "their legality should not change solely because of the subjective purpose of defending management control." It said existing Supreme Court precedents have also recognized that the reciprocal shareholding system can serve as a means of stabilizing management control.
The two sides also disagree over the significance of the ruling. Youngpoong Corporation and MBK Partners say it has exposed problems with the legitimacy of the current management's governance structure, while Korea Zinc maintains that existing shareholders' meeting resolutions do not automatically lose their effect solely because of an unfinalized first-instance ruling.
The appeal is expected to focus not only on the requirements for reciprocal shareholdings to be established, but also on the purpose of acquiring shares through affiliates and whether restricting existing shareholders' voting rights constitutes an abuse of rights. How a higher court reconciles the differing decisions in the injunction proceedings and the main lawsuit is also drawing attention.
An IB industry source said, "People are watching to see whether this lawsuit could lead to a legal precedent that draws the line between the scope of domestic companies' defense of management control and the protection of shareholder rights in the future."
[email protected] Kim Kyung-a Reporter