Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Manager Kim and Manager Park Each Contributed 10 Million Won to Their Pensions ... A 'Shock' in Their Account Balances 20 Years Later

Input
2026-11-17 04:40:00
Updated
2026-11-17 04:40:04
File photo. Getty Images Bank
File photo. Getty Images Bank

[Financial News] Even when people contribute the same principal to their retirement pensions, the assets they have in retirement can differ by hundreds of millions of won depending on how their assets are allocated, how they enroll, and how they receive their pension, a simulation has found. On the 16th, the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) distributed a “Retirement Pension Guidebook” featuring such examples and urged subscribers to actively manage and review their pensions.

Diversified investing vs. principal- and interest-guaranteed products: an asset gap of 157.28 million won after 20 years

According to an example in the FSS guidebook, when a total principal of 200 million won is contributed to a retirement pension over 20 years at 10 million won annually, the final accumulated amount varies dramatically depending on the investment strategy.
Applying actual returns from 2006 to 2025, the final assets grew to 429.48 million won when investments were diversified across stocks and bonds, as with the National Pension Service (NPS). By contrast, when the money was invested mainly in principal- and interest-guaranteed products such as time deposits and installment savings, the final assets stood at just 272.2 million won. Even with the same principal contributed, the difference in investment returns alone came to 157.28 million won. As the effects of compounding accumulated through the reinvestment of returns, the gap between the two accounts—which was 3.94 million won in the fifth year—widened to about 160 million won by the 20th year.
As of the end of June this year, domestic retirement pension assets surpassed 558 trillion won, continuing to grow in scale. The share of performance-linked products (those not guaranteeing principal and interest) also rose to 35.5%, about three times the 2023 level, with 50.4% of these investments flowing into exchange-traded funds (ETFs). However, 64.5% of all subscribers still keep their entire accumulated balances in principal- and interest-guaranteed products, while even subscribers who invest tend to concentrate their holdings in ETFs tied to specific sectors rather than benefiting from diversification—a pattern of “herd investing.”
The FSS therefore recommended actively using pension-specific products such as target-date funds (TDFs) and default options (the pre-designated investment system), which automatically allocate assets according to a person’s retirement date and investment profile.
In-person vs. online IRP fees differ by 8.2 million won ... pension payouts bring in 186.42 million won more

The savings on fees also varied considerably depending on how an account was opened. In a comparison involving an individual retirement pension (IRP) account funded with 200 million won in retirement benefits and 60 million won in personal contributions, a person who enrolled in person at Securities Firm A or a bank branch paid 8.2 million won in investment and asset management fees over 10 years. By contrast, a person who enrolled remotely with Financial Institution B paid no fees at all over the same period. Existing in-person account holders can also reduce their fees by using their financial institution’s online conversion program.
The difference in the amount actually received depending on whether severance pay is taken as a lump sum or in pension installments came close to 190 million won. If a 55-year-old employee takes 500 million won in severance pay as a lump sum, 45 million won in retirement income tax is withheld at source, leaving 455 million won in hand.
By contrast, if the money is transferred to an IRP account, invested at an annual return of 3%, and received as pension payments of 25 million won a year over an extended period, the after-tax amount received rises to 641.42 million won—186.42 million won more than with a lump-sum payment. This is because, in addition to the tax benefit of reducing retirement income tax by 30% in years 1–10, 40% in years 11–20, and 50% from year 21 onward, the remaining balance continues to be invested and earn interest before each withdrawal. Even someone who has already received severance pay as a lump sum can get a refund of the retirement income tax paid by redepositing the money into a pension account within 60 days of receiving it.
Meanwhile, the “Retirement Pension Guidebook,” published by the FSS early this month, has drawn a strong response. Within a week of its release, it had been downloaded as a PDF 89,000 times from the FSS Integrated Pension Portal, and requests for additional print orders reached 25,000 copies—five times the initial print run of 5,000. The guidebook is available free of charge through the FSS Integrated Pension Portal, the websites of individual retirement pension providers, and the e-book platforms Millie’s Library and Kyobo eBook.

[email protected] Moon Young-jin Reporter