Court: “Revocation of Doctor’s License for ‘Drunk, Unlicensed Driving’ Is Justified” ... Also Rejects Constitutional Referral Request
- Input
- 2026-11-16 14:09:49
- Updated
- 2026-11-16 14:09:49

[Financial News] The court has issued its first ruling that the so-called “Doctor License Revocation Act” (the amended Medical Service Act), which requires revoking the license of a doctor sentenced to imprisonment or a more severe penalty for an ordinary crime unrelated to medical practice, is not unconstitutional.
The Seoul Administrative Court’s 12th Administrative Division, presided over by Judge Kang Jae-won, said on the 16th that it had ruled against Doctor A in a lawsuit seeking to overturn the revocation of A’s medical license, which A had filed against the Minister of Health and Welfare. The panel also dismissed A’s request to refer the amended Medical Service Act provision for constitutional review.
Doctor A was put on trial on charges of driving under the influence without a license in November 2023, with a blood alcohol concentration of 0.121%, and in May the following year was sentenced at the first trial to one year in prison, suspended for two years. After both the appeal and the final appeal were dismissed and the sentence became final, the Ministry of Health and Welfare revoked A’s medical license last July under the amended Medical Service Act.
A then filed an administrative lawsuit, arguing, “Revoking a license as a mandatory measure solely because a person has been sentenced to imprisonment or a more severe penalty for an ordinary crime unrelated to medical practice violates the principle of proportionality and infringes the freedom to pursue an occupation.”
Articles 65(1) and 8(5) of the Medical Service Act, amended in May 2023, stipulate that medical professionals’ licenses must be revoked if they are sentenced to imprisonment or a more severe penalty, including a suspended sentence, for any crime except occupational negligence resulting in death or injury. In the past, licenses were revoked only when someone had been punished for violating the Medical Service Act or other laws related to medical practice. Critics had argued that doctors could keep their licenses even after committing serious ordinary crimes such as sex crimes or drunk driving.
The panel ruled, “Members of the public, who have no choice but to entrust their lives, bodily integrity and health to medical professionals, expect them to have a high level of moral and ethical awareness as well as professional expertise,” adding, “It is only natural, as a matter of public legal sentiment, to expect treatment from a law-abiding citizen who has never committed an ordinary crime showing a lack of respect for the law, such as drunk driving.”
The panel added, “Securing trust in medical professionals is an important and urgent public interest for all members of the community,” and “Under the Medical Service Act, license revocation is a temporary measure, not permanent deprivation. When someone receives a suspended sentence of imprisonment or a more severe penalty for an ordinary crime, the potential for social condemnation is by no means insignificant, so the measure cannot be considered an excessive infringement on the freedom to pursue an occupation.”
This is the first case in an administrative lawsuit in which the court has ruled in favor of the constitutionality of the 2023 amendment to the Medical Service Act after it was applied in practice. The ruling is expected to serve as a benchmark in appeals filed by medical professionals whose licenses were revoked under the same provisions.
[email protected] Lee Chang-hoon Reporter