Monday, November 16, 2026

Middle Schooler Who Used AI to Make a Song Mocking a Friend and Snipped the Friend's Clothes With Scissors Loses Lawsuit Challenging School Bullying Measures

Input
2026-11-16 10:22:37
Updated
2026-11-16 10:22:37
Photo unrelated to the article./Photo: Yonhap News

[Financial News] A middle school student who bullied a friend by making a song mocking them with an artificial intelligence (AI) app and tearing the friend’s clothes with scissors, among other acts, sued on the grounds that the school bullying measures were unfair but lost.
On the 16th, the 1st-3rd Administrative Division of the Busan District Court, presided over by Judge Junseo Heo, dismissed the claim brought by middle school student A against the head of the Busan Haeundae Office of Education, seeking to overturn measures imposed on a student responsible for school violence.
A was found to have bullied B, a first-year student at the same middle school, last year by hiding B’s belongings, poking B in the side and swearing at B in places such as the computer lab. A also grabbed B by the collar or tore B’s clothes, and even used an AI app to make a song mocking B. On January 6 this year, A pushed B in the chest, grabbed B around the waist and knocked B down, then hit B on the head and cut B’s vest with scissors.
The Haeundae Office of Education’s School Violence Countermeasures Deliberation Committee determined that these acts constituted school violence and ordered A not to contact, threaten or retaliate against the victimized student and others. It also imposed six hours of school service, four hours of special education for A and four hours of special education for A’s guardian.
A then filed a lawsuit, arguing that some of the alleged acts were not true, that the circumstances surrounding the school violence had not been properly taken into account, and that the measures were too severe.
However, the court found that school violence had occurred, noting that the accounts given by the victimized student and student witnesses were consistent and that A had admitted to some of the acts. It also found it appropriate for the School Violence Countermeasures Deliberation Committee to assign A’s conduct a total of six points: one for severity, two for persistence, one for intent, one for degree of remorse and one for degree of reconciliation. That score falls within the four-to-six-point range for which school service may be imposed on a student responsible for school violence.
The court ruled, “Measures for school violence are intended both to protect victimized students and to guide and educate students responsible for the violence,” adding, “It is difficult to conclude that the disadvantages the plaintiff will suffer are more significant than the public interest the measures seek to achieve.”
[email protected] Kim Su-yeon Reporter