“Replace the investigative team”: No change despite six complaints... recusal requests accepted in only 37% of cases
- Input
- 2026-11-09 16:12:20
- Updated
- 2026-11-09 16:12:20


[Financial News] A case has emerged in which a complaint seeking a change of the investigative team and an internal inspection over alleged inadequate police work was sent back to the very team targeted by the recusal request. Requests to recuse investigators over inadequate investigations and dissatisfaction with investigative conduct have surged, while acceptance rates have fallen each year, raising questions about the system’s effectiveness.
Both internal inspections and supplementary investigations remain stalled
According to reporting by Financial News on the 9th, Kim, who filed a fraud complaint with Pyeongtaek Police Station in Gyeonggi Province, raised allegations of inadequate investigation and requested a change of investigative team and an internal inspection. However, the related complaints were handled by the existing team or Pyeongtaek Police Station.After police decided not to refer the case on September 16, Kim filed a total of six complaints and petitions with the National Police Agency, the Gyeonggi Nambu Provincial Police Agency and the Suwon District Prosecution Office. Kim alleges that police treated even transactions in which the suspect sent money back as repayments and failed to properly verify the actual unrecovered amount of 19.2 million won.
Kim filed a request to recuse the investigator through e-People on September 29, but received a response on the 16th of last month from the existing investigative team—the very team targeted by the request. Pyeongtaek Police Station also responded to the request for an internal inspection submitted to the Gyeonggi Nambu Provincial Police Agency, while the petition filed with the Suwon District Prosecution Office was likewise transferred to Pyeongtaek Police Station and closed.
The department that issued the original decision not to refer the case is also handling the supplementary investigation. Even a complaint asking the National Police Agency headquarters’ Inspector General’s Office to handle the matter directly was closed on the 2nd on the grounds that it was repetitive and duplicative. In effect, although the person who raised the allegations of inadequate investigation challenged the existing team’s impartiality, the case review and handling of related complaints were once again carried out by the same police station.
At least 6 out of every 10 recusal requests rejected
Although more people are expressing dissatisfaction with investigations and seeking to have the investigator in charge replaced, the proportion of recusal requests actually accepted is falling instead.According to the National Police Agency’s “Status of Recusal Requests Filed Against Investigators,” 5,471 such requests were filed nationwide from January to September this year, already exceeding the 5,401 filed over all of last year.
In particular, requests citing dissatisfaction with investigative conduct, inadequate investigations or insufficient protection of the right to defense totaled 2,951 through September this year, up 24.1% from 2,378 for all of last year. Their share of all recusal requests also grew from 44% last year to 53.9% this year.
By category, requests citing dissatisfaction with investigative conduct totaled 1,477 from January to September this year, up 20.8% from 1,223 for all of last year. Requests citing inadequate investigations also rose 23.7%, from 951 to 1,176 over the same period. Requests alleging that the right to defense was not sufficiently protected during an investigation increased 46.1%, from 204 to 298, the largest rise among the categories.
By contrast, the acceptance rate for investigator recusal requests fell each year, from 63% in 2022 to 58% in 2023, 44% in 2024, 39% in 2025 and 37% from January to September this year. That is a drop of 26 percentage points in just over four years. Although more people are challenging investigative fairness and seeking to have the investigator in charge replaced, the proportion of requests actually accepted continues to decline.
The problem is that even when the Prosecution Office requests a supplementary investigation, it is difficult to compel a change of the police station or investigative team in charge. It can request that the adequacy of the investigation’s findings be reviewed, but the police decide through their internal procedures which station or team will be assigned the case. Separate grounds are also required to transfer a case from the police station with existing jurisdiction to another station.
A Prosecution Office official explained, “The Prosecution Office cannot direct that a case be reassigned to a specific police station or investigative team,” adding, “Because investigative jurisdiction has already been established, it is difficult to transfer a case to another police station solely because a complainant has questioned the fairness of the investigation.” The official continued, “If you believe there is a problem with investigative fairness, you should raise the matter directly with the police,” and added, “There are also cases in which a matter is reassigned to another police station or investigative team in the process.”
[email protected] Lee Dong-hyeok, reporter
[email protected] Lee Dong-hyeok Reporter