Monday, November 23, 2026

Today's Supreme Court of Korea Audit... 'Renewed Recommendation of a Supreme Court Justice' Emerges as Key Issue

Input
2026-10-06 09:06:39
Updated
2026-10-06 09:06:39
On the 5th, a day before the National Assembly audit, an eerie silence hung outside the meeting room of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee of the National Assembly in Yeouido, Seoul. News1
[Financial News] Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae's refusal to comply with Cheong Wa Dae's request for a renewed recommendation of a Supreme Court justice is expected to emerge as the key issue at the National Assembly audit of the Supreme Court of Korea on the 6th. Although Cho refused to appear as an ordinary witness, his attendance in the capacity of head of the institution is a separate matter, raising questions about whether he will state his position in opening remarks. The parties are also expected to clash over responsibility for the vacancy among Supreme Court justices, which has continued for 218 days.
The Legislation and Judiciary Committee of the National Assembly will conduct an audit at 10 a.m. that day in Seoul's Yeouido of the Supreme Court of Korea, the National Court Administration, the Sentencing Commission, and the Judicial Policy Research Institute (JPRI). Led by the Democratic Party of Korea and other ruling parties, the committee designated Chief Justice Cho as an ordinary witness, but he submitted a written explanation for his absence on the 2nd.
Cho's side cited judicial independence as the reason. According to Seo Young-kyo, chair of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee, Cho's side submitted an opinion stating that the National Assembly may require his attendance under Article 121 of the National Assembly Act, but that he has no obligation to attend, take an oath, or testify. However, attendance as a witness and attendance as head of the institution are separate matters. As a result, there is speculation that Cho could, as he did last year, state his position on the renewed recommendation issue in opening remarks at the audit.
The ruling and opposition parties clashed over whether Cho should appear as a witness. The Democratic Party of Korea demanded, "Do not hide behind a thin opinion that does not even accord with the interpretation of the law. Appear boldly as a witness at the audit and explain yourself directly to the people." Seo said, "The chief justice is not untouchable," and even raised the possibility of issuing a compulsory attendance order. The People Power Party countered, "Calling the chief justice, one of the three senior state officials, to a National Assembly audit is an abuse of legislative power and bullying against the judiciary that runs counter to the separation of powers," adding, "If the chief justice is called as a witness, then the president should also appear as a witness at the National Assembly audit of the executive branch."
The root of the conflict is the vacancy among Supreme Court justices. After former Justice Rho Tae-ak retired on March 2, the vacancy became a reality as the recommendation of his successor was delayed. Six months later, on August 18, Cho recommended Judge Son Bong-gi of the Daegu District Court and Judge Kim Sung-soo together. However, Cheong Wa Dae, saying there had been no substantive consultation between the president and the chief justice, did not submit the appointment-consent motion for nominee Son to the National Assembly and requested a renewed recommendation on August 28, 10 days later. On the 22nd of last month, Cho stated that he would not comply with the request for a renewed recommendation. In an additional statement the following day, he countered that it was difficult to accept the claim that the procedure contained defects.
Article 104, Paragraph 2 of the Constitution stipulates, "A Supreme Court justice is appointed by the president with the consent of the National Assembly upon the recommendation of the chief justice of the Supreme Court." The authority to make the recommendation itself belongs exclusively to the chief justice. However, the government has handled the task of forwarding the recommendation to the National Assembly. A former official who previously worked at the Ministry of Government Legislation explained that Article 52 of the Constitution grants the right to submit bills only to National Assembly members and the government, leaving the judiciary with no channel to submit documents directly to the National Assembly. As a result, a convention was established under which the government submits recommendation letters and other documents sent by the judiciary to the National Assembly. In other words, even if the chief justice makes a recommendation, the process stops at that point if the government does not forward it.
Meanwhile, questioning is expected to continue even if Cho avoids answering. The ruling camp plans to question Noh Gyeong-pil, head of the National Court Administration, and others about the circumstances behind the refusal to make a renewed recommendation and who bears responsibility for prolonging the vacancy.
Questions are also expected about President Lee Jae Myung's criminal trial. The Democratic Party of Korea has argued that the Supreme Court's process of quashing and remanding Lee's appeal in the case involving alleged violations of the Public Official Election Act on May 1 last year was excessively rapid.
Meanwhile, the Legislation and Judiciary Committee will conduct a National Assembly audit of the Ministry of Justice on the 8th. Issues expected to arise include whether the system involving the Public Prosecution Office and the Serious Crime Investigation Agency, launched after the abolition of prosecutors' offices, will become established, as well as the controversy over withdrawing the indictment in Lee's case.
[email protected] Kim Dong-gyu Reporter