"South Korea Must Maintain an Overwhelming Technological Lead to Cement Its Advantage... Government R&D Support Essential" [The Shadow of the Semiconductor Boom]
- Input
- 2026-09-29 18:14:15
- Updated
- 2026-09-29 18:14:15


For more than a decade, China has invested not in semiconductors that generate profits, but in semiconductors that can survive. The National Integrated Circuit Industry Investment Fund, known as the Big Fund, was established several times by the Chinese government starting in 2014. Its total funding, calculated by simply adding the amounts from each round, has reached 686.7 billion yuan, or approximately 139 trillion won. The central government and state-owned financial sector provided funding through the Big Fund, while local governments offered additional support, creating a foundation that allowed semiconductor companies to withstand prolonged losses and industry downturns. ChangXin Memory Technologies (CXMT), which survived through this support, has now emerged as a major global competitor in commodity DRAM and is accelerating capacity expansion on the back of the recent memory boom.
Chris Miller, a professor at Tufts University and author of the global bestseller Chip War, sees technological leadership across all fields as South Korea’s answer to China’s semiconductor rise. His assessment is that Korea must not compete with China solely on production capacity. To maintain a long-term competitive advantage, it must continue widening the technological gap while it still holds the lead.
The problem is that the unit of competition is no longer limited to individual companies. China’s semiconductor drive is being backed by state funding, local governments, and the financial sector. Voices are calling for South Korea to respond with a public-private one-team approach, rather than relying solely on investments by individual companies such as Samsung Electronics and SK hynix. Under this approach, the government would take responsibility for long-term R&D and research infrastructure while companies strengthen their technological and production capabilities.
■ China Already a Major Player in Commodity DRAM
In a written interview with Financial News on the 29th, Miller warned, "In high-performance products, the technology gap between Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Chinese companies remains substantial. It will be difficult for CXMT to secure a significant share of the HBM market over the next several years." He added, "In commodity DRAM, however, CXMT is already becoming an important player."
Miller believes CXMT has rapidly improved its technological capabilities in consumer DRAM, but still trails South Korean companies by a considerable margin in advanced products, including HBM. "CXMT is struggling with high-performance data-center products, including HBM," he said. "One reason is that it does not have extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography equipment, and at present it has no way to obtain it."
Regarding the possibility that Chinese memory companies could eventually reach or surpass the technological level of global leaders such as Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Micron, he ruled out that prospect in the near term.
The situation is different in commodity DRAM. Asked whether the existing memory market, dominated by Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Micron, could be reshaped into a competitive landscape that also includes Chinese companies, Miller said, "This is already happening with basic DRAM products."
Chinese semiconductor companies have also been pursuing a series of initial public offerings this year to secure large amounts of funding. CXMT raised up to 66.6 billion yuan, or approximately 13.51 trillion won, through its listing in July and became the largest company by market capitalization on mainland China’s stock exchanges immediately after listing. Yangtze Memory Technologies (YMTC), China’s leading NAND flash memory company, has also applied for an IPO and is proceeding with the listing process. The offering is expected to raise 33 billion yuan, or approximately 6.7 trillion won.
Miller focused less on the IPO itself than on the capacity expansion it would facilitate. "CXMT plans to expand its production capacity on a relatively larger scale," he predicted. "It will clearly gain a larger market share in consumer and other low-margin DRAM products."
■ Technology Ultimately Key to Countering China’s Catch-Up
U.S.-led export controls on advanced semiconductor equipment are considered a key factor that will determine the pace of growth in China’s memory industry.
Even after the recent U.S.-China summit, there has been no major change in U.S. semiconductor export controls targeting China. Miller said, "The only factor limiting CXMT’s ability to compete with Samsung Electronics and SK hynix is its lack of access to the advanced semiconductor manufacturing equipment needed to produce high-performance DRAM cost-effectively." He added, "If export controls are tightened further, CXMT will face difficulties expanding its production capacity."
He proposed continued technological innovation as South Korea’s response. "Continued technological innovation is important for maintaining the competitiveness of South Korea’s semiconductor industry," he emphasized.
He also cited U.S. export controls on Chinese semiconductor companies, including CXMT, as an important factor. Regarding the technology cooperation already taking place between Korean and U.S. companies, Miller said, "Korean memory companies are already working closely with U.S. AI and graphics processing unit (GPU) companies to develop higher-performance memory semiconductors."
■ Risky to Give Up Commodity DRAM and Go All-In on AI Semiconductors
In South Korea, there are calls to maintain competitiveness across the entire range from commodity DRAM to HBM. Alongside companies’ technological competition, the government must also provide long-term R&D support.
Seok-jun Kwon, author of China Semiconductor Rising and a South Korean semiconductor expert, said in an interview with this publication, "This is the most dangerous time to think that we should give commodity memory to China and have Korean companies go all-in on AI semiconductors." He continued, "We can maintain our share of HBM only if we have a share of DRAM," predicting that Korean companies’ pricing power could also weaken if they lose their share of commodity DRAM and CXMT rises to the level of one of the world’s two leading players.
Kwon believes competition with China is fundamentally different from the game of chicken Korean companies previously played with Japanese companies. "Korean companies have played games of chicken with Japanese memory semiconductor companies, but they have never done so with China," he said. "The reason competition with China cannot be taken lightly is that this is not a company-versus-company game of chicken." He added, "Korea has companies taking the lead, but China has companies plus the government."
He also considers the government’s role equally important. The state must support long-term R&D and research infrastructure that companies find difficult to invest in immediately. "Research involving various forms of trial and error clearly needs to be carried out," Kwon said. "But companies do not have unlimited resources, and if they have money to spend, they would rather increase production. The government must support research that is essential."
Specifically, he proposed dedicated R&D fabs and international joint semiconductor research centers. "I hope the government will play the role of a player that lays the groundwork without interfering — creating infrastructure without meddling — so that it can become a new hub for testing South Korea’s next-generation semiconductor processes, materials, and various device technologies," Kwon said.
Ultimately, the roles need to be divided: companies should strengthen their technological and production capabilities, while the government should support long-term R&D and research infrastructure. Kwon also called for policy continuity. "Institutional continuity and a certain degree of consistency must be maintained," he emphasized.
[email protected] Eun-hyo Jo, Soo-bin Lim, and Hak-jae Kim Reporter