Supreme Court Rules, "Debts Must Still Be Paid Even if a Claim Under Provisional Attachment Is Rescinded by Agreement"; Precedent Changed After 25 Years
- Input
- 2026-09-30 07:41:21
- Updated
- 2026-09-30 07:41:21

The Supreme Court Grand Bench, presided over by Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae with Justice Kwon Young-jun as the presiding justice, set aside a lower court ruling against the plaintiff in an appeal of a lawsuit seeking payment of collected funds on the 29th and remanded the case to Ulsan District Court. The decision was unanimous among all 11 justices who participated.
The plaintiff was a creditor of a monetary claim held by Company A, which operated a biogas power generation business in Gyeongju. After Company A transferred the business to Company B for 850 million won, the plaintiff obtained a provisional attachment of 350 million won of the claim for the transfer price. The plaintiff later obtained an order converting the provisional attachment into a formal attachment and collection order. In the meantime, Company B and Company A rescinded the transfer agreement by mutual consent and argued that they had no obligation to pay on that basis.■ "The Debtor Should Bear the Risk of Rescission by Agreement After Attachment"The previous legal doctrine was established in a Supreme Court of Korea ruling handed down in June 2001. It held that, unless the debtor and the third-party debtor had rescinded the contract in a special case solely to extinguish the claim, the third-party debtor could invoke the rescission against the creditor.
The Supreme Court Grand Bench overturned that doctrine after 25 years. The court stated, "A rescission by mutual agreement is essentially no different from a disposition of the claim itself, as it is an act by the debtor that extinguishes the claim subject to attachment while the effect barring disposition is in force." It explained that because rescission by mutual agreement involves a new contract concluded after the attachment, rather than the exercise of a right reserved before the attachment, it cannot be treated in the same way as statutory or contractually stipulated rescission.
The court reached the same conclusion after weighing the competing interests. It stated, "As a general rule, it is appropriate for the debtor to bear the legal risks triggered by a rescission by mutual agreement after attachment in the relationship between the attaching creditor and the debtor." Regarding cases in which the debtor is insolvent, the court emphasized, "It is appropriate for the third-party debtor, which chose to take that risk and agreed to the rescission, to bear it. The risk should not be shifted to the attaching creditor, who is unrelated to the rescission."■ Exceptions Also Recognized; Third-Party Debtor Must Prove ThemThe Supreme Court Grand Bench, however, recognized three exceptions: when the requirements for statutory or contractually stipulated rescission are met but the parties merely adopted the form of rescission by mutual agreement; when the claim subject to attachment is a future right to a portion arising from a continuing contract; and when special circumstances make it clearly unreasonable to deny the rescission's effect against the attaching creditor solely because of the attachment, in light of the content and nature of the contract and claim, the claim's contractual significance, and the circumstances surrounding the rescission. The third-party debtor seeking to invoke one of these exceptions must prove it directly.
The court found that the third-party debtor would not be unfairly disadvantaged. The party can be relieved of its payment obligation by making a deposit with the court for enforcement purposes. It can also have the debtor deposit the amount required to release the provisional attachment and thereby have the enforcement canceled. If it is compelled to perform, it can seek reimbursement from the debtor for the corresponding amount.
Both the first and second trials rejected the plaintiff's claim under the previous doctrine, holding that it was difficult to view the agreement as a rescission aimed solely at extinguishing the claim without a reasonable reason. The Supreme Court of Korea found that the legal doctrine underlying those rulings no longer applied. At the same time, it noted that the lower courts had not examined whether the case fell within an exception to the new doctrine, leaving that issue for the remand proceedings.
A Supreme Court of Korea official explained that the ruling is significant because it discarded the previous doctrine, which had led in most cases to the categorical conclusion that rescission by mutual agreement after attachment of a claim was permissible. The new ruling instead gives priority to the purpose of the enforcement system—satisfying claims by converting attached assets into cash—and protects the interests of attaching creditors over the debtor's freedom to dispose of assets.
The Supreme Court Grand Bench consisted of 11 members because former Supreme Court Justice Lee Heung-gu retired on the 7th, while Noh Gyeong-pil did not participate in the full-bench hearing scheduled for July 22 after taking office as head of the National Court Administration on July 14. There was also one vacant seat among the Supreme Court justices.
[email protected] Kim Dong-gyu Reporter