Monday, November 23, 2026

[Exclusive] Accessed the internal network just before consulting, but former LG Energy Solution employee's prison term reduced from 3 years to 2

Input
2026-08-19 14:23:54
Updated
2026-08-19 14:23:54
Seoul High Court. Yonhap News Agency

[Financial News] A former LG Energy Solution employee, who was sentenced to prison at first instance for stealing trade secrets related to secondary batteries, a national core technology, and using them in paid consulting, had his sentence reduced on appeal. The court found that access to the company cloud PC just before the consulting session, or merely reviewing internal materials, was not enough to conclude that he had actually disclosed trade secrets.
According to the legal community on the 19th, Criminal Division 15-3 of the Seoul High Court, presided over by judges Sung Eon-ju, Won Ik-seon and Lee Hee-jun, sentenced former LG Energy Solution executive and business development staff member A to two years in prison and ordered the forfeiture of about 6.6 million won on the 10th of last month on charges including violating the Unfair Competition Prevention and Trade Secret Protection Act. At the first trial, he was sentenced to three years in prison and ordered to forfeit about 15.8 million won.
A was indicted on charges of disclosing company trade secrets, including electric vehicle process technology and foreign substance management standards, during paid consulting engagements.
The court ruled that simply accessing the company's cloud system did not mean he had actually viewed trade secrets, and acquitted him of some charges. The first trial had treated records showing that A accessed the company cloud PC shortly before consulting on secondary battery inspection methods in April and May 2021 as evidence of guilt.
The appeals court noted, "Although A's access history has been confirmed, no objective evidence has been submitted to show that he viewed or downloaded trade secret materials from the cloud, such as access logs or download packet records." It added that he also accessed the system for work purposes even on days when he had no consulting sessions during overseas business trips, and that there was no evidence that related materials were stored on the cloud PC or received by email.
The court also held that the mere fact that the consulting topics were related to the company's leaked trade secrets was not enough to establish actual disclosure. In the first trial, A was found guilty of consulting in 2021 and 2022 with a Japanese consulting firm on an IT system for manufacturing automotive batteries, and with a foreign consulting firm on the electric vehicle and battery value chain.
The appeals court said it was not specifically established what questions were asked and what answers were given. The panel stated, "Without specifically identifying what information or trade secrets the client in the paid consulting asked about regarding the victim company, it is impossible to determine the specific content of the trade secrets based only on the assumption that such information could have been discussed." It also considered that the consulting topics were broad and that the related materials included content that was not a trade secret.
As some of the trade secret disclosure charges were overturned, part of the charge under the Act on Regulation and Punishment of Criminal Proceeds Concealment was also acquitted.
However, the convictions for the remaining trade secret leaks were upheld. The court said, "Despite a confidentiality obligation, A committed the offenses over a long period while evading the company's monitoring and controls," adding that "the nature of the crime is highly poor and the grounds for criticism are substantial." The court took into account that there was no evidence that the trade secrets were immediately passed on to a competitor and used. Both the prosecution and A have appealed, and the case is now before the Supreme Court of Korea.
[email protected] Choi Eun-sol Reporter