"Japanese Media's 'Modern-Day Guilt by Association' Comment Draws Rebuttal from Seo Kyoung-duk: 'Start with a Proper Understanding of History'"
- Input
- 2026-08-15 06:40:00
- Updated
- 2026-08-15 06:40:00

[Financial News] After Japanese media criticized the controversy over actress Ha Young's great-grandfather as a modern-day form of guilt by association, Professor Seo Kyoung-duk of Sungshin Women's University pushed back. He said, "Japanese media have no right to make such criticism."
On the 14th, Seo criticized Japan via his social networking service (SNS), saying, "Which country distorted the history of forced labor and had it listed as a UNESCO World Heritage site?"
Earlier, on the 12th, the Japanese outlet JB Press covered the controversy surrounding Ha Young in a column titled, "Why Does South Korea Not Forgive the Descendants of Pro-Japanese Collaborators?" The outlet argued, "There has long been a 'scarlet letter' attached to the South Korean entertainment industry. That stigma is none other than being the descendant of a pro-Japanese collaborator." It added, "The issue is the past actions of a great-grandfather whom Ms. Ha has never even met. It is an incomprehensible situation."
Hiromi Kamoshika, a guest commentator for Fuji Television Network, also addressed the issue in a separate column. He said, "There is a saying in South Korea that if you fight for independence, your family will suffer for three generations, but if you collaborate with Japan, your family will prosper for three generations." He added that while it is important not to forget the past, making even advertisements private because of allegations involving a great-grandfather amounts to a modern-day form of "guilt by association."
Seo responded by pointing to Japan's own problems in how it views history. He said, "Has Japan ever offered sincere apologies and compensation to the grandmothers who were forced into military sexual slavery?" He added, "Japan is the country that still insists, absurdly, that Dokdo belongs to it."
Seo also criticized Japanese media, saying, "Japanese media should first act with a proper understanding of history, and only then criticize other countries." He argued that they have no standing to cover the controversy.
After Ha Young's great-grandfather was identified as Ahn Sang-ho, known as a doctor during the Japanese colonial period, controversy erupted on social networking services over Ahn's past activities. Ahn had previously worked as a member of the pro-Japanese group Daejeong Friendship Association, and he was also named as a figure involved in theories that Emperor Gojong of the Korean Empire was poisoned.
Following the controversy, Ha Young posted a handwritten apology on her SNS on the 12th. She apologized, saying, "In my ignorance, I spoke about my great-grandfather in various settings as if it were something my family could be proud of." She added, "I will continue to study our history together and do my best to honor independence activists and all those who devoted themselves to the liberation and well-being of our resilient nation with respect."
[email protected] Han Seung-gon Reporter