"The plunge in Samsung and SK hynix is over, buy now" — then they sold anyway: the double standard of foreign IBs
- Input
- 2026-08-11 09:54:48
- Updated
- 2026-08-11 09:54:48

[Financial News] Investor trust in securities firm reports is wavering. The reason is the wide gap in target prices that different brokerages assign to the same stocks.
183 reports on SK hynix alone... Highest target price at 4.7 million won, current share price at 1.4 million won
On the 11th, The Korea Economic Daily reported, citing financial data provider FnGuide, that domestic brokerages issued a total of 13,368 company analysis reports on 605 KOSPI and KOSDAQ-listed stocks from January 1 through the 7th of this month.
The stocks with the widest target-price gaps were the semiconductor leaders. In 183 reports issued this year on SK hynix, the highest target price was 4.7 million won from Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., while the lowest was 750,000 won, a 6.3-fold difference. Samsung Electronics showed a 4.3-fold gap, from 150,000 won at Sangsangin Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. to 650,000 won at Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., across 237 reports. Hyundai Motor Company also showed a wide range, from 340,000 won to 1.2 million won. By contrast, the gaps were relatively smaller for LG Energy Solution, at 342,000 won to 670,000 won, and Doosan Enerbility, at 100,000 won to 165,000 won.
The gap between target prices and actual share prices was also significant. According to The Korea Economic Daily, as of the 7th's closing price, the gap between recent average target prices from brokerages in July and August and market prices was highest for SK hynix at 146.87%. That means the average target price set by brokerages was about 2.5 times the actual share price. Samsung Electronics followed at 117.28%, then SK Square at 115.65%, Hyundai Motor Company at 86.94%, and Doosan Enerbility at 69.62%.
Individual investors are also increasingly complaining that target prices that differ by hundreds of thousands of won per stock are hard to use as a basis for investment decisions.
Morgan Stanley says "time to re-enter," but ranks among the top sellers
Another factor adding to investors' confusion is the disconnect between foreign Investment Bank (IB) reports and actual trading activity.
In an Asia technology stock report released on the 6th, Morgan Stanley said, "The sharpest correction seen so far in the memory industry appears to be over," and added, "Valuations offer an attractive tactical re-entry opportunity." The report drew even more attention because Shawn Kim, the Morgan Stanley analyst who wrote it, was the same person who had correctly flagged the slowdown in the memory cycle in his 2021 report, "Memory, Winter Is Coming."
Actual trading trends, however, showed a different picture. As of 11 a.m. on the 10th, Morgan Stanley, JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs and other foreign IBs that had recently issued bullish outlooks were listed among the top selling channels for Samsung Electronics and SK hynix.
The securities industry says research reports and actual trading behavior should be viewed separately. The fact that a firm appears among the top selling channels does not by itself prove that its report was wrong or that it misled investors. Sales can occur for many reasons, including client order execution and portfolio rebalancing.
[email protected] Kim Soo-yeon Reporter